Cliff # 1

About cliffeconomics

This blog offers original economic thought and policy recommendations on Germany, the euro area, and whatever cliff has on his mind.

123

Friday, August 17, 2012

Euro breakup: Who cares about accounting losses?

With the "Merkel memorandum", The Economist has joined the rows of other commentators on the cost of a euro breakup. The costs are quantified as accounting losses on bailout loans, ECB's bond holdings and Target2 balances, and possibly bank bailouts. Is this all the euro crisis is about? Hardly. The numbers the Economist bases its argument on are accounting losses and fall short of the cost-benefit analysis it claims to be. Here are a few arguments why Frau Merkel will not be impressed by accounting losses:Losses on bailout loans. It is correct that the paid-out loans may not be repaid as scheduled, prompting Eurostat to reassess their recording as financial investment by creditor countries. But creditor countries could find ways to avoid taking an accounting losses, such as by rescheduling the loans. As the paid-out loans are already funded, a breakup does not increase...

Will Germany become Spain?

This great collection of quotes, comprised by an analyst at Fairfax, an investment bank, has made rounds on the Internet: "Spain is not Greece." - Elena Salgado, Spanish Finance minister, February 2010. "Portugal is not Greece." - The Economist, April 2010. "Greece is not Ireland." - George Papaconstantinou, Greek Finance Minister, November 2010. "Spain is neither Ireland nor Portugal." - Elena Salgado, Spanish Finance Minister, November 2010. "Ireland is not in ‘Greek Territory.’" - Brian Lenihan, Irish Finance Minister, November 2010. "Neither Spain nor Portugal is Ireland." - Angel Gurria, Secretary General OECD, November 2010. "Spain is not Uganda." - Mariano Rajoy, Spanish Prime Minister, June 2012. "Uganda does not want to be Spain." - Henry Okelo Oryem, Unganda Foreign Minister, June 2012. And what is Germany? Let's step back. European integration and the euro...

Friday, June 15, 2012

Why Germany wants to keep Greece in the euro area

Germany had a good crisis---this is how the commentator Satyajit Das, Roubini's fellow blogger and author of "Traders, Guns, and Money"---nicely puts it. Since the subprime crisis spilled over the Atlantic, Germany's output took a leap forward above pre-crisis levels, unemployment plummeted, the budget deficit vanished, and household net wealth grew to about EUR225,000 per household. Today, ECB's monetary policy gives an additional stimulus with interest rates at 1 percent whereas the Taylor rule suggests 4.5 percent would be more appropriate (compared to 2009 when ECB first dropped rates to that level). Recently, the euro started depreciating,...